top of page

Scripture Alone

Nov 9
3 min read

At Unite Leadership Collective (ULC), we believe meaningful conversations include a diversity of perspectives, even when we disagree. Guest articles reflect the views and opinions of their respective authors and do not necessarily represent those of ULC or its leadership. Our decision to publish an article is an invitation to thoughtful dialogue, not an endorsement of every position expressed. We encourage readers to engage with grace, curiosity, and a commitment to truth.


Where in the Bible is residential pastoral formation required?


Bylaws: man-made.

Resolutions: man-made.


Yes…bylaws and resolutions are voted on by Christians sent by local congregations to conventions for conversation and decisions to harmoniously walk together.  Good.  Healthy.  And yet, resolutions and bylaws are man-made, not God-breathed.



We believe, teach, confess...


Our good works should not be lifted to God to merit His love, grace, or favor.  We have all things by grace, through faith, in Christ alone. 


Likewise, we cannot lift man-made writings, of which Synod bylaws and resolutions reside, to the position where there is room for only one voice. God’s Voice. Specifically: Scripture Alone.


The Bible: norms, it is not normed.

The Bible: infallible, unchanging. 

The Bible: sole, final, authority.


We stand alone—on the Word of God.


Except when we don’t.

Except when I don’t.


When my life reflects thoughts, words, and deeds not taught in God’s Word or at odds with God’s Word, I am wrong. I have sinned.  Confession and Absolution—the path toward healing and new life. 


Not just me, an example for us: Pastoral formation.  Where in the Bible is residential pastoral formation required?


Pastoral letters? Yes.

Pastoral qualification? Yes.

How a pastor is trained, formed? Adiaphora.


There is no Biblical command for how pastors are to be formed.  And yet, the LCMS has bylaws, norming faith and practice around pastoral formation, not commanded in God’s Word.  Yes, not forbidden, and so freedom to suggest and advise. But not forbidden does not mean freedom to command.


When bylaws are mandating things around pastoral formation that are not mandated in God’s Word, what does this mean?


Can man mandate what God has not mandated?  When this occurs, is it faithful?


Commanding what God has not commanded is not Scripture Alone.  The Bible + anything inconsistent or not present in the Bible is not Sola Scriptura; it is Scripture +.


Pastoral formation is good.

Pastoral formation is also adiaphora.

Four years of residential education is good.

Four years of residential education is also Adiaphora.

Four years of residential education being called the standard, or gold standard is opinion.


God’s Word, the standard, is Scripture Alone.


God’s Word has not mandated four years residential education. God’s Word has not mandated residential education period.


And that is not to say four years of residential education is not good. It is good.  But it’s not commanded or forbidden. It’s a choice. One cannot be faithful to the Bible and believe residential pastoral formation is the only choice.


Synod: man-made.

Synod bylaws: man-made.

Synod resolutions: man-made.

God’s Word: God-made.

The Church: God-made.


There are words for that which is man-made, mandating to what is God-made, where God has not spoken...faithful is not one of them.


Man-made bylaws and resolutions, at their best, reflect the beauty and truth of God's Word.  At their worst, they command what God has not commanded.  


God creating and establishing His Church, giving each local church the Office of the Keys, the local church having the God-given right to call a man to the Office of the Holy Ministry, the local church then also decides how pastoral formation occurs, as the local church decides all other adiaphora.


If the local church decides residential Seminary education is what they want for their pastor, beautiful.


If the local church would prefer training and formation in and through their local congregation (a different form of residential education), also beautiful.


What norms our faith and our practice? Scripture Alone.  Where Scripture has not mandated, the church has freedom. 


Increased options for pastoral formation, with God’s local people deciding local practices not commanded by God’s Word: Biblical. Confessional.




 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page